Chris Chmielenski's picture


  by  Chris Chmielenski

In just a few short months, Roy's much-anticipated 2010 update to his original Immigration Gumballs presentation has reached the 1 Million views milestone on YouTube. Supporters of mass immigration will argue that the U.S. has a moral obligation to open its borders to the world's needy, but Roy's visual presentation provides a different perspective and has been well received.

Many of the 1 Million viewers didn't stumble across "Immigration, World Poverty and Gumballs" through YouTube or Google searches. Most were referred to the video through social media, friends and family, and links from related articles and columns. For those of you who helped spread the message, we extend a million thanks!

Since October, the video has received 978 comments and 1,812 "Likes" on YouTube with 96% of the ratings being positive. The presentation has reached young and old and a worldwide audience. More than 108,000 in Canada, 43,064 in Europe, 3,976 in Asia, and 13,113 in Australia have watched the video.

Wtih all the views, comments, and ratings, "Immigration, World Poverty, and Gumballs" is one of the highest ranked immigration videos on YouTube. In a search for "immigration" on YouTube, the presentation lists third on the second page. Our goal is to get it to the top of the first page, so please continue to post it to your blogs and social media pages, share with your friends and family, and comment and rate the video!

Just last week, a journalism student from John Carroll University near Cleveland, Ohio came across the video. In watching it, Michael Reiser related the presentation's message to an immersion trip he took with other schoolmates to the Dominican Republic. Witnessing the poverty in that country firsthand, Michael thought about the impact of a U.S. immigration policy that took the Dominican's best and brightest away from its country instead of providing support to those people in their own country. Michael's story is just one of hundreds that we've come across over the past several months, but the fact that it was published just last week and in a college newspaper made it stand it.

Here's Michael's column as published in The Carroll News (reprinted with permission)...

We’re not the only 'Land of Opportunity'

by Michael Reiser 

Along with 12 of my fellow students, I partook in one of the school’s immersion trips over winter break to the Dominican Republic and had a wonderful experience. After witnessing the lack of opportunity for the people that we met in one of the nation’s many small villages (called bateys) made up of poor sugar cane farmers that make about $1 per day, I tried to put myself in their shoes and wondered what I would do to try to get out of their poverty stricken situation.

My immediate plan would be to emigrate to the U.S. as soon as possible. So many immigrants have come to the “Land of Opportunity” recently that immigration has become one of the most contested issues on the political stage over the past 20 years. The classic liberal claims (to go along with humanitarian arguments) America was built on immigrants, so what merit did past immigrants have over the present day ones knocking on our door? The classic conservative (popularly caricaturized with the famous line from South Park “They took our jobs!”) is generally against raising immigration levels. I have always felt very torn on the subject, more so after my immersion experience.

I recently watched a presentation by author/journalist Roy Beck, entitled “Immigration, World Poverty, and Gumballs” which gave me a better perspective on the matter. Beck illustrates that, according to the World Bank, 3 out of the 7 billion people in the world make less than $2 per day. Compare that to the average American who makes $120 daily. Each year, the U.S. takes in one million immigrants. Beck believes going as far as doubling this rate would not only be futile in the effort against world poverty, but would actually exacerbate the problem.

When the U.S. accepts immigrants from these poor countries, we are going to accept the highly educated and healthy ones. Obama wants to bring more of these immigrants in from other countries to help boost American competitiveness. I was talking to fellow junior Patrick Burns at lunch the other day and we came to an interesting point. It’s good to be competitive and we should want to be the best nation in the world. But when it’s at the expense of other countries, particularly poor countries, it becomes wrong and rather selfish. Taking the cream of the crop from places like the Dominican hurts those countries and helps only a sliver of their population.

We learned on the trip that the goal of what we were trying to do was to help the people we worked with help themselves. Taking their best and brightest is not helping them help themselves. The idea is not to work for them, but rather with them. Simply giving to the poor doesn’t do anything, nothing is instilled in the culture.

Using immigration as a way to fight world poverty is an irrational and ineffective weapon (and in my opinion, rather pretentious). Poor countries need their best and brightest, bringing them to the U.S. for our advancement is a rather selfish thing to do. As Beck said in his presentation, “They have to be helped where they live.” Find out more at

CHRIS CHMIELENSKI is the Website Content Manager for NumbersUSA

Illegal Immigration
world poverty
Gumball Video

Updated: Fri, Jul 21st 2017 @ 11:22am EDT

NumbersUSA's blogs are copyrighted and may be republished or reposted only if they are copied in their entirety, including this paragraph, and provide proper credit to NumbersUSA. NumbersUSA bears no responsibility for where our blogs may be republished or reposted. The views expressed in blogs do not necessarily reflect the official position of NumbersUSA.