Take Action
Fax Congress free Urge your Representative and Senators to oppose guestworker-amnesty bills
Related Bills & Information
Find the latest information and analysis on the current congressional immigration reform debate at our
Congressional Immigration Action Center
The Price of American Citizenship in Comparison to Typical Expenses Incurred by Average Americans
NumbersUSA; July 2007
President Bush Holding Immigration Enforcement and Homeland Security Hostage to Amnesty Plan
— NumbersUSA, March 9, 2007
President Bush's Plan For Comprehensive Immigration Reform01/23/2007
Bush Immigration Proposal Built On Misconceptions, Analysis by NumbersUSA President Roy Beck
Comparison of the Main Immigration Enforcement, Guest Worker, and Amnesty Bills in the 109th Congress
Side-by-side Comparison of the Specter, Sensenbrenner and Frist Bills
NumbersUSA,
Updated March 20, 2006
Co-sponsors of
S. 1033
Co-sponsors of
H.R. 2330
Additional Reading
Bill page links to statements by sponsors, section-by-section summary, and other resources

Immigration Is Hurting The U.S. Worker
Center for Immigration Studies; Spring 2007

Bilbray: What Part of 'Illegal Immigration' is Confusing?
Human Events; 05/03/2007


Each Low-Skill Illegal Alien Household Costs U.S. Taxpayers $1.1 Million Over a Lifetime
— The Heritage Foundation; April 4, 2007


The hidden cost of illegal workers
Christian Science Monitor; March 19, 2007

ICE can’t handle an amnesty-guestworker program
Testimony of former ICE official Michael Maxwell

Sensenbrenner Releases Report on Immigration; Strong Enforcement of Immigration Laws, Tough Sanctions Can Reduce Illegal Immigration
House Committee on the Judiciar
y via U.S. Newswire ; May 5, 2006

Immigrant Entry and Native Exit
From the Labor Market, 2000-2005

CIS, March 2006

The Connection Between Legal and Illegal Immigration
CIS, February 2006


Report Shows Last Five Years Highest Immigration in History
CIS, December 2005


Mc-Kennedy amnesty: 12 million served

10 Principles for Immigration Reform

The Visa Lottery - A Result of the Special Interests on U.S. Immigration Law , May 25, 2005 Congressional Testimony of NumbersUSA Director of Government Relations Rosemary Jenks

Jobs Americans WILL Do (by occupation)

A Century of Expert Immigration Commissions Agree: AgJOBS Is Bad Policy


‘Occupation Collapse’ and Poverty Wages:
Consequences of Large Guestworker Programs
, Testimony of Roy Beck before the House Immigration Subcommittee on Immigration, Border Security, and Claims

Amnesty and Guestworker/amnesty

Bush Plays More Word Games With Immigration

by James R. Edwards

This article originally appeared in Human Events on February 8, 2007



In his next to last State of the Union Address, President Bush once more called for the irresponsible, self-destructive immigration policy of mass amnesty.

The President unfortunately showed he has learned nothing from the bitter debate that has churned throughout the nation for the past few years. The "decider in chief" has decided upon the wrong immigration stance, once more.

Damaged Credibility

Even worse, he continued to strain credulity -- and stretch thinner his credibility. In the bad old days, President Bill Clinton visited upon himself a credibility crisis by blatant, arrogant abuse of language, even fudging on the meaning of "is."

Now the current President won't shoot straight on how he would deal with illegal aliens. All President Bush said was that "we need to resolve the status of the illegal immigrants who are already in our country -- without animosity and without amnesty." He then again called for "comprehensive immigration reform" -- a euphemism he has repeatedly used for mass amnesty of every last illegal alien.

To conservatives who thought they were getting someone who wouldn't play word games with the American people, President Bush has been a disappointment when immigration is the subject. He just will not plainly admit that to legalize and give eventual U.S. citizenship to at least 12 million law-breaking foreigners now among us is pure and simple amnesty.

'Chain Migration'

The Bush amnesty plan would supposedly "take pressure off the border" by "establish[ing] a legal and orderly path for foreign workers to enter our country to work on a temporary basis."

But this is only a half-truth. He failed to mention that the "temporary" work program he has in mind would not be temporary at all. Every illegal alien already here will get a "temporary" visa.

Those same illegal aliens are then rewarded with an eventual green card and later citizenship. All would be allowed to sponsor their extended family members in lengthy "chain migration."
There's no reason to think those chain migrants would act any differently from the third of current legal immigrants who sneak into America illegally and live here unlawfully until their green card number comes up.

While "they won't have to try to sneak in," most certainly will. The only way to process all those illegal aliens and their distant relatives in a lawful and orderly way is with visa quotas and reasonable screening procedures. The only alternative is to open the borders to all comers -- hardly a law-and-order proposition.

To have heard President Bush, you'd think we have no temporary work visas. But we have about 10 types already. They work out with different degrees of success, and each has its share of problems and unintended consequences.

For example, H2As are for foreign agricultural workers. Yet, agriculture is the occupational sector employing the most illegal aliens. H1Bs allow in skilled workers who regularly displace skilled Americans in fields such as high-tech.

The President also fibbed about his administration's commitment to enforcing immigration laws faithfully. He said: "To secure our border, we are doubling the size of the Border Patrol and funding new infrastructure and technology."

Yet this administration is trying to weasel out of building a border fence, which Congress plainly called for. President Bush favors a "virtual fence," which really means the illegals sneak across open land, some expensive technology detects them, and Border Patrol agents have to try to catch them inside our country before they disappear.

"We will enforce our immigration laws at the worksite and give employers the tools to verify the legal status of their workers." Really? When? We already have employer sanctions laws that President Bush has been lax in enforcing.

This administration has steadily turned a blind eye toward the jobs magnet. Only a handful of companies have received sanctions. In the big-headline raids of the past year, the public wasn’t told that most of the illegal aliens arrested were released within a few hours.

This administration even pared back sending employers "no-match" letters when it became embarrassing to have the public learn that -- as HUMAN EVENTS has often pointed out -- hundreds of thousands of aliens are working under fake or stolen Social Security numbers. Tens of thousands even use the obviously bogus Social Security number of 000-00-0000. But Bush does nothing.

Congress made a now-10-year-old electronic employment verification program available to employers nationwide nearly four years ago, but participation remains voluntary.

Mr. President, please quit the word games. Start doing your duty by starting finally to enforce the immigration laws already on the books.

Mr. Edwards, coauthor of The Congressional Politics of Immigration Reform, is an adjunct fellow with the Hudson Institute.
Amnesty and Guestworker/amnesty
Border Patrol Agents Ramos & Compean
REAL ID Act
Previous Hot Topics:
Immigration-related recommendations of the 9-11 Commission
Matricula Consular
Key Statistics

SSA Commissioner
Barnhardt and her counterpart in Mexico signed a totalization
agreement on June
29, 2004. The agreement would allow both legal AND illegal aliens working in the United States to qualify for Social Security benefits. The estimated cost of the agreement is disputed, but some estimates run as high as $345 billion over the next 20 years.

Some 12 million or more illegal aliens broke our immigration laws to work illegally in this country (stealing jobs and wages from American workers), and nearly all of them would be rewarded by the Bush proposal with legal permits to keep the jobs they stole—at least for three years.
U.S. Amnesties for Illegal Aliens
Congress has passed 7 amnesties for illegal aliens, starting in 1986
Harvard professor finds that, by increasing the supply of labor, immigration between 1980-2000 cost native-born American men an average $1,700 in annual wages by the year 2000. Native-born Hispanic and black Americans suffered the greatest loss of wages from this immigration.
Public Opinion
Polls show a majority of Americans oppose amnesty
Zogby Poll Shows Americans Prefer House Approach on Immigration
CIS;
May 3, 2006
Important Opposition
Border Patrol agents
American Federation of Government Employees
Fred Barnes,
Weekly Standard
National Review
The Nixon Center
Robert Reich, Former Sec. Of Labor





 
Back to Top