Hot Topics
- 5 Great Immigration-Reduction Bills
- Comprehensive Amnesty Threat
- Foreign Worker Timeout
- February 5, 2010 EST - posted on NumbersUSA
Senators Urge Majority Leader Reid to Include Immigration-Related Amendments in Jobs Bill - January 8, 2010 EST - posted on NumbersUSA
Jobless Rate Remains the Same, but 85,000 More Jobs Cut in December - December 14, 2009 EST - posted on NumbersUSA
Former Rep. Virgil Goode Calls for Immigration Moratorium - States Passing E-Verify Laws
- More Topics
- Recent Blogs



Gregory9503 of OH
Wed, 10/14/2009 - 7:09pm
I agree we need to stop
I agree we need to stop illegal immigration and deport those whom we find. But I have mixed feelings about a total suspension of legal immigration. I think this is too broad-brush. It is a fact that we are graduating fewer American-born engineers and scientists than we need, particularly those with advanced degrees. Most of those who come here become citizens, and do not leach money from taxpayers by becoming welfare recipients. Further, engineers and scientists do not just take a job for themselves; they create jobs for others. My estimate is at least a 20:1 ratio of new jobs created for each engineer or scientist hired. I don't know if anyone has actually studied this. PS: I am a engineer myself, American-born, and I have had the pleasure to work with many foreign-born engineers and scientists.
NumbersUSA Moderator: Thanks for your comments, Gregory. NumbersUSA advocates a suspension of all non-essential immigration. We don't advocate stopping immigration for spouses and minor children, or for true geniuses. As for other scientists and engineers: 20 percent of high-skilled immigrants in the U.S. Labor force is unemployed or working in an unskilled job; studies (herehere) finding no shortage of engineers in the U.S. and; found that the often-cited (by Sen. Kennedy, Newt
Gingrich and others) statistics that the U.S. produces 70,000 engineers
annually versus 350,000 from India and 600,000 from China are not valid.