Home > Hot Topics > More Topics > Health Care Reform > Poll Reveals Americans Believe High Immigration has had a Negative Impact on Health Care

Update

Poll Reveals Americans Believe High Immigration has had a Negative Impact on Health Care

Congressmen Who...

  • Voted to Prevent a Vote on Illegal Alien Verification Amendments to Health Care Reform Bill
    Updated Monday, November 9, 2009, 1:04 PM EDT
November 7, 2009 -- Voted to Prevent a vote on Illegal Alien Verification Amendments in Health Care Bill
A "Yes" vote prevents a vote on illegal alien verification amendments
A "No" vote allows a vote on illegal alien verification amendments
Voted YES Count: 242
Voted NO Count: 192
  • (AR-D) Berry
  • (AR-D) Ross
  • (AR-D) Snyder
  • (AZ-D) Giffords
  • (AZ-D) Grijalva
  • (AZ-D) Kirkpatrick
  • (AZ-D) Mitchell
  • (AZ-D) Pastor
  • (CA-D) Baca
  • (CA-D) Becerra
  • (CA-D) Berman
  • (CA-D) Capps
  • (CA-D) Cardoza
  • (CA-D) Chu
  • (CA-D) Costa
  • (CA-D) Davis
  • (CA-D) Eshoo
  • (CA-D) Farr
  • (CA-D) Filner
  • (CA-D) Garamendi
  • (CA-D) Harman
  • (CA-D) Honda
  • (CA-D) Lee
  • (CA-D) Lofgren
  • (CA-D) Matsui
  • (CA-D) McNerney
  • (CA-D) Miller
  • (CA-D) Napolitano
  • (CA-D) Richardson
  • (CA-D) Roybal-Allard
  • (CA-D) Sanchez, Li.
  • (CA-D) Schiff
  • (CA-D) Sherman
  • (CA-D) Speier
  • (CA-D) Stark
  • (CA-D) Thompson
  • (CA-D) Waters
  • (CA-D) Watson
  • (CA-D) Waxman
  • (CA-D) Woolsey
  • (CO-D) DeGette
  • (CO-D) Markey
  • (CO-D) Perlmutter
  • (CO-D) Polis
  • (CO-D) Salazar
  • (CT-D) Courtney
  • (CT-D) DeLauro
  • (CT-D) Himes
  • (CT-D) Larson
  • (CT-D) Murphy
  • (FL-D) Boyd
  • (FL-D) Brown
  • (FL-D) Castor
  • (FL-D) Grayson
  • (FL-D) Hastings
  • (FL-D) Klein
  • (FL-D) Kosmas
  • (FL-D) Meek
  • (FL-D) Wasserman Schultz
  • (FL-D) Wexler
  • (GA-D) Barrow
  • (GA-D) Bishop
  • (GA-D) Johnson
  • (GA-D) Lewis
  • (GA-D) Scott
  • (HI-D) Abercrombie
  • (HI-D) Hirono
  • (IA-D) Boswell
  • (IA-D) Braley
  • (IA-D) Loebsack
  • (IL-D) Bean
  • (IL-D) Costello
  • (IL-D) Davis
  • (IL-D) Foster
  • (IL-D) Gutiérrez
  • (IL-D) Halvorson
  • (IL-D) Hare
  • (IL-D) Jackson Jr.
  • (IL-D) Lipinski
  • (IL-D) Quigley
  • (IL-D) Rush
  • (IL-D) Schakowsky
  • (IN-D) Carson
  • (IN-D) Donnelly
  • (IN-D) Ellsworth
  • (IN-D) Hill
  • (IN-D) Visclosky
  • (KS-D) Moore
  • (KY-D) Chandler
  • (KY-D) Yarmuth
  • (MA-D) Capuano
  • (MA-D) Delahunt
  • (MA-D) Frank
  • (MA-D) Lynch
  • (MA-D) Markey
  • (MA-D) McGovern
  • (MA-D) Neal
  • (MA-D) Olver
  • (MA-D) Tierney
  • (MA-D) Tsongas
  • (MD-D) Cummings
  • (MD-D) Edwards
  • (MD-D) Hoyer
  • (MD-D) Ruppersberger
  • (MD-D) Sarbanes
  • (MD-D) Van Hollen
  • (ME-D) Michaud
  • (ME-D) Pingree
  • (MI-D) Conyers
  • (MI-D) Dingell
  • (MI-D) Kildee
  • (MI-D) Kilpatrick
  • (MI-D) Levin
  • (MI-D) Peters
  • (MI-D) Schauer
  • (MI-D) Stupak
  • (MN-D) Ellison
  • (MN-D) McCollum
  • (MN-D) Oberstar
  • (MN-D) Peterson
  • (MN-D) Walz
  • (MO-D) Carnahan
  • (MO-D) Clay Jr.
  • (MO-D) Cleaver
  • (MS-D) Thompson
  • (NC-D) Butterfield
  • (NC-D) Etheridge
  • (NC-D) Kissell
  • (NC-D) McIntyre
  • (NC-D) Miller
  • (NC-D) Price
  • (NC-D) Watt
  • (ND-D) Pomeroy
  • (NH-D) Hodes
  • (NH-D) Shea-Porter
  • (NJ-D) Adler
  • (NJ-D) Andrews
  • (NJ-D) Holt Jr.
  • (NJ-D) Pallone
  • (NJ-D) Pascrell
  • (NJ-D) Payne
  • (NJ-D) Rothman
  • (NJ-D) Sires
  • (NM-D) Heinrich
  • (NM-D) Luján
  • (NM-D) Teague
  • (NV-D) Berkley
  • (NV-D) Titus
  • (NY-D) Ackerman
  • (NY-D) Arcuri
  • (NY-D) Bishop
  • (NY-D) Clarke
  • (NY-D) Crowley
  • (NY-D) Engel
  • (NY-D) Hall
  • (NY-D) Higgins
  • (NY-D) Hinchey
  • (NY-D) Israel
  • (NY-D) Lowey
  • (NY-D) Maffei
  • (NY-D) Maloney
  • (NY-D) Massa
  • (NY-D) McCarthy
  • (NY-D) McMahon
  • (NY-D) Meeks
  • (NY-D) Murphy
  • (NY-D) Nadler
  • (NY-D) Owens
  • (NY-D) Rangel
  • (NY-D) Serrano
  • (NY-D) Slaughter
  • (NY-D) Tonko
  • (NY-D) Towns
  • (NY-D) Velázquez
  • (NY-D) Weiner
  • (OH-D) Boccieri
  • (OH-D) Driehaus
  • (OH-D) Fudge
  • (OH-D) Kaptur
  • (OH-D) Kilroy
  • (OH-D) Kucinich
  • (OH-D) Ryan
  • (OH-D) Space
  • (OH-D) Sutton
  • (OH-D) Wilson
  • (OR-D) Blumenauer
  • (OR-D) DeFazio
  • (OR-D) Schrader
  • (OR-D) Wu
  • (PA-D) Brady
  • (PA-D) Carney
  • (PA-D) Dahlkemper
  • (PA-D) Doyle
  • (PA-D) Fattah
  • (PA-D) Holden
  • (PA-D) Kanjorski
  • (PA-D) Murphy
  • (PA-D) Murtha
  • (PA-D) Schwartz
  • (PA-D) Sestak
  • (RI-D) Kennedy
  • (RI-D) Langevin
  • (SC-D) Clyburn
  • (SC-D) Spratt
  • (SD-D) Herseth Sandlin
  • (TN-D) Cohen
  • (TN-D) Cooper
  • (TN-D) Davis
  • (TN-D) Gordon
  • (TN-D) Tanner
  • (TX-D) Cuellar
  • (TX-D) Doggett
  • (TX-D) Edwards
  • (TX-D) Gonzalez
  • (TX-D) Green
  • (TX-D) Green
  • (TX-D) Hinojosa
  • (TX-D) Jackson-Lee
  • (TX-D) Johnson
  • (TX-D) Ortiz
  • (TX-D) Reyes
  • (TX-D) Rodriguez
  • (UT-D) Matheson
  • (VA-D) Boucher
  • (VA-D) Connolly
  • (VA-D) Moran
  • (VA-D) Nye
  • (VA-D) Perriello
  • (VA-D) Scott
  • (VT-D) Welch
  • (WA-D) Dicks
  • (WA-D) Inslee
  • (WA-D) Larsen
  • (WA-D) McDermott
  • (WA-D) Smith
  • (WI-D) Baldwin
  • (WI-D) Kagen
  • (WI-D) Kind
  • (WI-D) Moore
  • (WI-D) Obey
  • (WV-D) Mollohan
  • (WV-D) Rahall
  • (AK-R) Young
  • (AL-D) Bright
  • (AL-D) Davis
  • (AL-D) Griffith
  • (AL-R) Aderholt
  • (AL-R) Bachus
  • (AL-R) Bonner
  • (AL-R) Rogers
  • (AR-R) Boozman
  • (AZ-R) Flake
  • (AZ-R) Franks
  • (AZ-R) Shadegg
  • (CA-D) Sanchez, Lo.
  • (CA-R) Bilbray
  • (CA-R) Bono Mack
  • (CA-R) Calvert
  • (CA-R) Campbell
  • (CA-R) Dreier
  • (CA-R) Gallegly
  • (CA-R) Herger
  • (CA-R) Hunter
  • (CA-R) Issa
  • (CA-R) Lewis
  • (CA-R) Lungren
  • (CA-R) McCarthy
  • (CA-R) McClintock
  • (CA-R) McKeon
  • (CA-R) Miller
  • (CA-R) Nunes
  • (CA-R) Radanovich
  • (CA-R) Rohrabacher
  • (CA-R) Royce
  • (CO-R) Coffman
  • (CO-R) Lamborn
  • (DE-R) Castle
  • (FL-R) Bilirakis
  • (FL-R) Brown-Waite
  • (FL-R) Buchanan
  • (FL-R) Crenshaw
  • (FL-R) Diaz-Balart
  • (FL-R) Diaz-Balart
  • (FL-R) Mack
  • (FL-R) Mica
  • (FL-R) Miller
  • (FL-R) Posey
  • (FL-R) Putnam
  • (FL-R) Rooney
  • (FL-R) Ros-Lehtinen
  • (FL-R) Stearns
  • (FL-R) Young
  • (GA-D) Marshall
  • (GA-R) Broun
  • (GA-R) Deal
  • (GA-R) Gingrey
  • (GA-R) Kingston
  • (GA-R) Linder
  • (GA-R) Price
  • (GA-R) Westmoreland
  • (IA-R) King
  • (IA-R) Latham
  • (ID-D) Minnick
  • (ID-R) Simpson
  • (IL-R) Biggert
  • (IL-R) Johnson
  • (IL-R) Kirk
  • (IL-R) Manzullo
  • (IL-R) Roskam
  • (IL-R) Schock
  • (IL-R) Shimkus
  • (IN-R) Burton
  • (IN-R) Buyer
  • (IN-R) Pence
  • (IN-R) Souder
  • (KS-R) Jenkins
  • (KS-R) Moran
  • (KS-R) Tiahrt
  • (KY-R) Davis
  • (KY-R) Guthrie
  • (KY-R) Rogers
  • (KY-R) Whitfield
  • (LA-D) Melancon
  • (LA-R) Alexander
  • (LA-R) Boustany
  • (LA-R) Cao
  • (LA-R) Cassidy
  • (LA-R) Fleming
  • (LA-R) Scalise
  • (MD-D) Kratovil
  • (MD-R) Bartlett
  • (MI-R) Camp
  • (MI-R) Ehlers
  • (MI-R) Hoekstra
  • (MI-R) McCotter
  • (MI-R) Miller
  • (MI-R) Rogers
  • (MI-R) Upton
  • (MN-R) Bachmann
  • (MN-R) Kline
  • (MN-R) Paulsen
  • (MO-D) Skelton
  • (MO-R) Akin
  • (MO-R) Blunt
  • (MO-R) Emerson
  • (MO-R) Graves
  • (MO-R) Luetkemeyer
  • (MS-D) Childers
  • (MS-D) Taylor
  • (MS-R) Gregg Harper
  • (MT-R) Rehberg
  • (NC-D) Shuler
  • (NC-R) Coble
  • (NC-R) Foxx
  • (NC-R) Jones
  • (NC-R) McHenry
  • (NC-R) Myrick
  • (NE-R) Fortenberry
  • (NE-R) Smith
  • (NE-R) Terry
  • (NJ-R) Frelinghuysen
  • (NJ-R) Garrett
  • (NJ-R) Lance
  • (NJ-R) LoBiondo
  • (NJ-R) Smith
  • (NV-R) Heller
  • (NY-R) King
  • (NY-R) Lee
  • (OH-R) Austria
  • (OH-R) Boehner
  • (OH-R) Jordan
  • (OH-R) LaTourette
  • (OH-R) Latta
  • (OH-R) Schmidt
  • (OH-R) Tiberi
  • (OH-R) Turner
  • (OK-D) Boren
  • (OK-R) Cole
  • (OK-R) Fallin
  • (OK-R) Lucas
  • (OK-R) Sullivan
  • (OR-R) Walden
  • (PA-D) Altmire
  • (PA-R) Dent
  • (PA-R) Gerlach
  • (PA-R) Murphy
  • (PA-R) Pitts
  • (PA-R) Platts
  • (PA-R) Shuster
  • (PA-R) Thompson
  • (SC-R) Barrett
  • (SC-R) Brown
  • (SC-R) Inglis
  • (SC-R) Wilson
  • (TN-R) Blackburn
  • (TN-R) Duncan
  • (TN-R) Roe
  • (TN-R) Wamp
  • (TX-R) Barton
  • (TX-R) Brady
  • (TX-R) Burgess
  • (TX-R) Carter
  • (TX-R) Conaway
  • (TX-R) Culberson
  • (TX-R) Gohmert
  • (TX-R) Granger
  • (TX-R) Hall
  • (TX-R) Hensarling
  • (TX-R) Johnson
  • (TX-R) Marchant
  • (TX-R) McCaul
  • (TX-R) Neugebauer
  • (TX-R) Olson
  • (TX-R) Paul
  • (TX-R) Poe
  • (TX-R) Sessions
  • (TX-R) Smith
  • (TX-R) Thornberry
  • (UT-R) Bishop
  • (UT-R) Chaffetz
  • (VA-R) Cantor
  • (VA-R) Forbes
  • (VA-R) Goodlatte
  • (VA-R) Wittman
  • (VA-R) Wolf
  • (WA-D) Baird
  • (WA-R) Hastings
  • (WA-R) McMorris Rodgers
  • (WA-R) Reichert
  • (WI-R) Petri
  • (WI-R) Ryan
  • (WI-R) Sensenbrenner
  • (WV-R) Capito
  • (WY-R) Lummis

A recent survey conducted by the American Council for Immigration Reform reveals that 78 percent of Americans believe that high immigration numbers have had a negative impact on the cost and quality of the nation's health care system.

The poll also revealed that the feelings are shared by the majority of Democrats and Republicans alike. While 89 percent of Republicans believe immigration has had a negative impact on health care quality and costs, 69 percent of Democrats also have the same opinion.

Other key findings from the poll are:

  • 73% of likely voters agreed that hospitals should be allowed to inquire and collect data about the immigration status of those seeking Emergency Room care
  • 77% believed that providing health insurance to illegal immigrants will just encourage more illegal immigration.
  • 83% of likely voters were very or somewhat concerned that the United States will add 135 million people to its population in the next 40 years
  • 78% of likely voters were opposed to legalizing the status of the estimated 12 million illegal immigrants in the U.S.

A separate survey conducted by Pulse Opinion Research revealed that the majority of likely voters who classify themselves as liberals or progressives oppose benefits to illegal aliens in any health care reform legislation. The poll found:

  • 53% oppose providing healthcare to undocumented aliens
  • 46% felt that current proposals would likely provide coverage to illegal immigrants
  • 48% felt that providing healthcare to undocumented immigrants would likely lead to increased healthcare costs.

In the News

Immigration Still at Play in Obamacare

In the News - Thursday, March 18, 2010

The immigration issue could still muck up Obamacare. And the liberal Congressional Hispanic Caucus might end up supporting bars to illegal aliens from federal health care.

This issue’s fallen relatively silent — compared with attention to the Senate health bill’s loose language on abortion — since Rep. Joe Wilson pointed out illegal alien loopholes in the House Obamacare bill.

By James R. Edwards -- National Review Online

http://healthcare.nationalreview.com/post/?q=OGI0YmQ4NTFjYTlmNzdkMjRmMGUwZjJiMGY3MTU4ODM=