Home > Issues > Amnesty > With Jobless Rates Like These, How Can Anybody Consider More Foreign Workers or an Amnesty?

With Jobless Rates Like These, How Can Anybody Consider More Foreign Workers or an Amnesty?

 

Official U.S. U-6 Unemployment Rates

 

 

 

 

 

Groups

All U.S.-born

Hispanic

U.S.-born

Black

U.S.-born

Young adults
(18-29) with
high school only

 

30.3%

 

32.7%

 

37.4%

 

High school
dropouts
(18-65)

 

33.2%

 

36.5%

 

42.0%

 

Teens in
work force
(16-17)

 

41.0%

 

48.1%

 

67.3%

 

SOURCE: From the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics U-6 unemployment report from June 2009 and the Census Bureau's American Community Survey. The government's U-6 Unemployment Rate counts not only people actively looking for a job who cannot find any kind of work, but it also counts "discouraged workers" who just recently stopped their unsuccessful quest for a job and those wanting a full-time job who have been forced into a part-time position.

Also see analysis of June report by Center for Immigration Studies at: http://cis.org/WorseThanItSeems

 

Do Unemployed Americans Deserve Suspension of Most Immigration?

The Americans represented in the above statistics are actively searching for a job and cannot find even a part-time job.

Those unemployed Americans in that table above primarily are looking for jobs in the same non-agricultural occupations where illegal foreign workers are currently employed – manufacturing, service, construction. An April 2009 study by the Pew Hispanic Center estimated that more than 8 million illegal foreign workers hold U.S. jobs. Any talk of legalizing those illegal workers is talk about keeping the Americans above out of those 8 million jobs.

Additionally, most of the hundreds of thousands of immigrants entering the country legally this year under extended-family categories and the visa lottery also will be competing for jobs with these unemployed Americans.

Isn’t the compassionate option to suspend most immigration (at the least,suspend chain-migration and visa lottery immigration) and stop making it more difficult for jobless Americans to find a job?