Home > Issues > Taxpayer Burden

Taxpayer Burden

 

Most illegal aliens are unskilled or low-skilled. The Nobel Prize-winning, liberal economist Paul Krugman has written, "Unfortunately, low-skill immigrants don't pay enough taxes to cover the cost of the benefits they receive.” That means American taxpayers must heavily subsidize the costs of services to newcomers. The financial burden on taxpayers occurs in many ways, including those noted below.

California Case Study on Immigration's Cost per Household

"The New Americans,” published by the National Research Council in 1997, is probably the most unbiased study ever conducted on the economics of immigration. The study found the tax burden of immigration to be $1,178 per native household in California.

Immigrants and Welfare Use

Immigrants to the United States are far more likely to use welfare (programs such as Medicare/Medicaid or food stamps) than native-born American families.  Nationwide, non-native households are 59% more likely to take advantage of a state or federal welfare program than a native household.

Amnesty Costs 70 Times More Than Enforcement

The cost of amnesty: $999 billion. The cost of attrition by enforcement: as little as $14 billion. Amnesty would cost up to 70 times as much as enforcing existing law.

“But they are funding the Social Security system” – Part II

The illegal alien lobby frequently touts the statistic that illegal alien workers contribute $7 billion each year to Social Security. But it costs $14.2 billion each year to imprison illegal aliens for other crimes they commit.

Tax Cost of Each Low-Skilled Immigrant Household

Robert Rector and Christine Kim of the Heritage Foundation calculated that an average low-skilled immigrant household costs federal, local, and state governments $19,588 per year more than it pays in all taxes.

Index of Taxpayer Burden Studies

The Center for Immigration Studies and the Heritage Foundation have published a number of reports over the years discussing the impact of immigration on the American taxpayer. Here's an index of those studies.

Immigration and School Costs

In California alone, immigration is responsible for more than 45% of the state's school children. This huge influx costs California's taxpayers more than $26 billion each year.

Myth: Amnesty and Increased Immigration are the easy solutions to the Social Security crisis

An amnesty for illegal aliens and increased legal immigration on top of that would only remedy a small portion of the social security deficit.

“But they are funding the Social Security system!”

The French word for duck is “canard.”  And in English, “canard” means, “A deliberately misleading fabrication.”  That is what the Social Security statistic is.
The illegal alien lobby frequently touts the statistic that illegal alien workers contribute $7 billion each year to Social Security. They fail to note that for every $1 illegal aliens contribute to Social Security, they withdraw $10 in other government benefits.

Illegal Immigration = $1 Billion Cost to Los Angeles Taxpayers (in 1 year)

The total cost of illegal immigration to Los Angeles County taxpayers alone exceeded $1 billion in 2008. Approximately $200 million is spent on public safety, $400 million for healthcare and $450 million to welfare and food stamps.

Amnesty's Huge Retirement Costs

Robert Rector of the Heritage Foundation estimated the cost of the 2007 Bush/Kennedy/McCain Amnesty bill to be at least $2.6 trillion in retirement costs over the following decades with American taxpayers bearing the burden.

In the News

Jury Rules for Hospital That Deported Patient

In the News - Tuesday, July 28, 2009

In a benchmark case dealing with the obligations of hospitals toward uninsured illegal immigrants, a jury in Stuart, Fla., decided Monday that Martin Memorial Medical Center did not act unreasonably when it chartered a plane and repatriated a severely brain-injured Guatemalan patient against the will of his guardian.

Judge James W. Midelis instructed the jury in state court late last week that because of a Florida appeals court decision, it was already “a matter of law” that the patient, Luis Alberto Jiménez, had been unlawfully detained and deprived of his liberty.

Still, the jury found that Martin Memorial had not committed false imprisonment and was not liable for damages.

By Deborah Sontag -- New York Times

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/28/us/28deport.html?_r=1

Illegal Immigrants May Pay Full Tuition Price

In the News - Saturday, July 25, 2009

Rep. Leo Berman, R-Tyler, said he has won a battle against illegal immigrants within the state regarding in-state tuition benefits with an opinion rendered Thursday night by the state attorney general's office.

Berman said despite his struggles to push immigration legislation during the recently convened legislative session, an opinion he filed more than a year ago will begin addressing benefits reserved for citizens.

By Adam Russell -- Tyler (Texas) Morning Telegraph

http://www.tylerpaper.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20090725/NEWS08/907250314

Bailing Out Illegals

In the News - Monday, July 13, 2009

Illegal aliens constitute about 7% of the state's population, or about 2.7 million, according to an April report by the Pew Hispanic Center. State officials say that they add about $4 billion to $6 billion in costs, primarily in the area of schools, prisons and jails, and emergency rooms. This is money the slightly less Golden State can scarcely afford.

For fiscal 2009-10, it's estimated that about $834 million will be spent to incarcerate 189,000 illegal immigrants in the state's prison system. In Los Angeles County alone, Supervisor Mike Antonovich says, illegal aliens add up to $550 million annually in criminal justice costs.

Investors.com

http://www.investors.com/NewsAndAnalysis/Article.aspx?id=481960

Illegal immigrants again in the budget spotlight

In the News - Friday, July 10, 2009

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has said it is wrong to blame illegal immigrants for the state's fiscal problems. He has, however, proposed to limit welfare and nonemergency healthcare for illegal immigrants and their families. So far, the Legislature has rejected his plans.

One of the governor's proposals would place a five-year limit on state welfare payments to the U.S.-citizen children of illegal immigrants. That would affect approximately 100,000 U.S.-born children in about 48,000 California households headed by illegal immigrants, who receive a monthly average of $472. The measure could save $77 million annually, according to the governor's office.

By Anna Gorman and Teresa Watanabe -- Los Angeles Times

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has said it is wrong to blame illegal immigrants for the state's fiscal problems. He has, however, proposed to limit welfare and nonemergency healthcare for illegal immigrants and their families. So far, the Legislature has rejected his plans.

One of the governor's proposals would place a five-year limit on state welfare payments to the U.S.-citizen children of illegal immigrants. That would affect approximately 100,000 U.S.-born children in about 48,000 California households headed by illegal immigrants, who receive a monthly average of $472. The measure could save $77 million annually, according to the governor's office.

Under another proposal, the governor could commute the sentences of some illegal immigrant felons in state prisons and shift them to federal detention centers. It costs the state $48,000 to incarcerate a prisoner, and the federal government reimburses about 12 cents on the dollar, according to state finance officials. The administration estimates that commuting sentences of 8,500 felons, along with other sentencing changes, could save $182 million, although other state analysts question that.

By Anna Gorman and Teresa Watanabe -- Los Angeles Times

Show More http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-illegal10-2009jul10,0,3398621.story

Insuring immigrants could cut cost of care for all

In the News - Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Yet nearly half of the recent immigrants (here for less than 10 years) with and without authorization already have insurance, said Leighton Ku, a George Washington University professor of public health policy.

An estimated 44 percent of recent immigrants are insured. That means they are working at companies that provide them with health insurance, whether they are authorized to be here or not. Although recent immigrants comprise 5 percent of the adult population, they account for only 1 percent of health expenditures.

By Jim Landers -- Dallas Morning News

http://www.dallasnews.com/sharedcontent/dws/bus/columnists/jlanders/stories/DN-landers_26bus.State.Edition1.1226edd.html

California faces its day of fiscal reckoning

In the News - Saturday, May 23, 2009

California is looking at a budget deficit projected at more than $24 billion when the new fiscal year starts in July. That is more than one-quarter of the state's general fund.

By Juliet Williams -- Associated Press

http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5iRGnvPzfCYCa9xXCbo2pS4KfTM4QD98BHNU02

Ky. Lawmakers Review Cost Of Illegal Immigration

In the News - Friday, May 15, 2009

A report approved by a state legislative committee Thursday shows the overall cost of illegal immigration on state and local governments is indeterminable, although it makes a couple recommendations on how some costs can be reduced.

The recommendations approved by the Program Review and Investigations Committee could help lower estimated costs of providing services to unauthorized, or illegal, immigrants at Kentucky’s public schools and at local jails.

Kentucky Post

http://www.kypost.com/news/local/story/Ky-Lawmakers-Review-Cost-Of-Illegal-Immigration/to1ya6dcy0G8OYdRD6ix9g.cspx

Personal pain from the front lines of immigration reform battle

In the News - Wednesday, May 13, 2009

"Margaret Heintz sputtered in frustration.

"There's nothing we can do," the Marshalltown, Iowa, woman said to her daughter, Mona Kilborn, when they talked about their shared point of aggravation -- illegal immigrants.

"Mom, you can do something," Kilborn said. "You can write your congressman. I'll even get you the address."

So in September 2007, the 90-year-old Heintz put pen to paper for her first letter to a politician. Two weeks later, she died at the hands of an illegal immigrant.

"Ironic, isn't it?" Kilborn said. "This one issue, it's changed our lives forever....""

Bekah Porter, (Dubuque, IA) Telegraph Herald, 13 May 2009

http://www.thonline.com/article.cfm?id=243128

Immigration raid leaves damaging mark on Postville, Iowa

In the News Quoted - Tuesday, May 12, 2009

"Since the landmark raid, an economic squeeze has destroyed several businesses. Postville's population has shrunk by nearly half, to about 1,800 residents, and townsfolk say the resulting anxiety -- felt from the deli to the schoolyard -- has been relentless.

"It's like you're in an oven and there's no place to go and there's no timer to get you out," said former Mayor Robert Penrod, who, overwhelmed, resigned earlier this year....

Roy Beck, head of the Washington-based NumbersUSA group that advocates for reducing immigration, argued that Postville invited its problems by relying so heavily on a plant many suspected was violating labor and immigration laws.

"The situation should have never gotten to that point," he said. "If you don't enforce the laws steadily, then when you suddenly enforce them, there is more collateral damage....""

Antonio Olivo, LA Times, 12 May 2009

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-postville-iowa12-2009may12,0,6761812.story

Opposing view: Invest in American workers

In the News - Tuesday, May 12, 2009

"One of President Obama's highest policy priorities is making America energy independent. The president has correctly observed that our reliance on others for essential energy needs is both a source of weakness and an impediment to the development of new technologies that would also strengthen our economy and help the environment.

In much the same way that we have avoided investing in domestic energy sources and new technologies, we have developed an unhealthy reliance on foreign workers to fill our science and technology needs. As technology has become increasingly important to our economy, U.S. companies have spent millions of dollars lobbying for increased access to foreign workers, rather than investing in American workers to fill jobs...."

Op-ed by Dan Stein, USA Today, 12 May 2009

http://blogs.usatoday.com/oped/2009/05/opposing-view-invest-in-american-workers.html

Polls

Half of Americans Believe Immigration Should be Reduced

Prefer Lower Numbers - Friday, August 7, 2009

A Gallup poll released on August 5, 2009 shows that 50% of all Americans believe that immigration should be reduced.  This number is 11 points higher than the figure from an identical poll conducted last year.  Only 14% of Americans say immigration should be increased (down from 18%) and 32% say immigration levels should remain the same (down from 39%).

5 August 2009, Gallup

http://www.gallup.com/poll/122057/Americans-Return-Tougher-Immigration-Stance.aspx

Most Arizona Voters Put Immigration Over Health Care as More Important Reform Goal

Prefer Lower Numbers Oppose Amnesty Support Tougher Enforcement Oppose Rewards for Illegal Migration - Monday, July 27, 2009

Fifty-one percent of Arizona voters say it is more important for Congress to pass immigration reform than health care reform.

By a 65% to 20% margin, Arizona voters believe enforcing the borders is more important than legalizing the status of those already living here. Half of the state’s voters (50%) think it is possible to put an end to illegal immigration, while 34% do not.

Rasmussen Reports, 27 July 2009

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/general_state_surveys/arizona/most_arizona_voters_put_immigration_over_health_care_as_more_important_reform_goal

Rasmussen Poll Shows 66% of Likely Voters Believe it is Important to Reduce Illegal Immigration

Oppose Amnesty Support Tougher Enforcement Oppose Rewards for Illegal Migration Opinion Elites vs. Public - Tuesday, April 14, 2009

A new Rasmussen poll shows that 66% of likely voters believe that the government should improve border enforcement and reduce illegal immigration.  However, only 32% of America's "Political Class" agree.

The poll also shows that 77% of likely voters believe that illegal aliens should not be able to receive driver's licenses and 73% of Americans believe that police officers should automatically check to see if someone is in this country legally when that person is pulled over for a traffic violation. 

Rasmussen Reports, 14 April 2009

http://www.rasmussenreports.com/public_content/politics/general_politics2/on_immigration_large_gap_remains_between_mainstream_america_and_political_class

Gannett Poll Finds NJ Residents Oppose Rewards for Illegal Aliens

Oppose Rewards for Illegal Migration - Tuesday, March 24, 2009

Sixty-two percent of state residents oppose granting illegal immigrants some type of limited driver's license, according to a Monmouth University/Gannett New Jersey poll.

Only 32 percent said children of illegal immigrants deserved in-state tuition rates, while 20 percent favored the lower rates for illegal immigrants themselves.

http://www.courierpostonline.com/article/20090324/NEWS01/903240343/1006/

Stats

Remittances

Stats - Wednesday, December 2, 2009

$1.69 billion in October 2009, nearly $1 billion less than October 2008. (SOURCE: Largest monthly drop in October since records began in 1996/The Associated Press, Dec. 1, 2009)